Changing payroll provider part way through the tax year

This post covers a change of provider on your own PAYE scheme, where you stay the employer. Moving staff to a new legal employer is a different exercise, and an employment law matter.
Keep each employment as one record
HMRC's April Employer Bulletin says employers continue to create duplicate employments when a payroll ID changes but the change indicator is not used. HMRC's systems then treat the new ID as a new job.
Its guidance for a continuing employee comes down to three points.
| Field | What HMRC asks for |
|---|---|
| Payroll ID, if it has changed | Tick the payroll ID change indicator, and give both the old and new IDs |
| Start date | Leave blank for continuing employments |
| Starter declaration | Do not submit one in place of the change indicator |
HMRC's guide to finding payroll software notes that some software will not let you continue with IDs used elsewhere, and that a bill may be calculated incorrectly, and records duplicated, if the indicator is not used. Ask how this will be dealt with before the first submission goes in.
Carry the year so far
The Full Payment Submission carries year to date figures for taxable pay, tax, student loans and National Insurance, as set out in HMRC's guide to payroll information. A new provider needs them for every continuing employee, so that the first submission follows on from the last. Practice differs on leavers from earlier in the tax year, so ask whether they will be entered as well.
Agree who extracts those figures, who checks them against the last submission, and who signs them off.
What else needs to move
- Current tax codes, and any recent notices from HMRC
- National Insurance categories and student loan plans
- Pay frequencies and pay dates
- Statutory payments in progress, with their dates and amounts
- Pension data
- Employer details: your PAYE and Accounts Office references
Then settle who receives HMRC's notices from the changeover date, and who sends what in the handover month.
Choosing the changeover
One option to weigh is a switch at the start of a tax month, which runs from the 6th, so that one provider's submissions cover each month's bill. Whatever the date, be clear about who sends the Employer Payment Summary due by the 19th, and who pays HMRC, electronically by the 22nd. Your people need paying on pay day throughout, and HMRC's payment is a separate event on its own date.
HMRC's guide to PAYE for employers adds that you are responsible for collecting and keeping employee records, and that you stay legally responsible for PAYE tasks even if you pay someone else to do them. So keep your own copy of the historic records.
If you are thinking about a move and want to talk through the timing, Alpine can go through it with you.
This is general information, not advice on your own position.
Reviewed against official sources, November 2026.
Sources
Talk to Alpine
If you have a question about your own payroll, we would be pleased to hear from you.
Get in touch

