Outsourced payroll or in house: the honest questions to ask

These are the questions we would start with.
How much work is really involved
List what happens in your payroll in a normal month. The running payroll guide gives the base: record pay, calculate deductions, produce payslips and report to HMRC on or before each payday, then claim any reductions by the 19th and pay by the 22nd of the next tax month.
Then add what sits around it. Starters, leavers, tax code notices, statutory pay, pension data and year end all take time, and some of that time falls in the same few days.
Who covers when your payroll person is away
If one person runs payroll, a holiday or an illness needs a plan. HMRC allows an early report when payroll staff are going on holiday, but warns against reporting too early, because changes then mean a corrected report. A good in house setup has a second trained person who has run a real pay cycle. With a provider, ask how cover works on their side.
The parts you want to keep close
Some businesses value having payroll close to HR, with answers available across a desk. Others would rather not have the work inside at all. Be honest about which describes you, and about whether staff would still have someone to ask.
| In house | Outsourced | |
|---|---|---|
| Choosing and updating software | You | Provider |
| Sending reports to HMRC | You | Agreed with the provider |
| Paying staff and HMRC | You | Agreed with the provider |
| Collecting employee details and keeping records of them | You | You, and the provider relies on them |
| Legal responsibility for PAYE tasks | You | You, under your own PAYE scheme |
Providers differ in how much support they offer, so the middle rows depend on what you agree. The last row does not move: HMRC says the responsibility for PAYE tasks stays with you as employer even if you pay someone else to do them.
How changes in the rules reach your payroll
Many rates change each April, and other changes arrive during the year. In house, someone has to read the bulletins and apply them. With a provider, ask how a change is applied and how you will hear about it.
Seeing the work
Whichever route you take, decide what you want to see and when, then test that against what you would receive.
What to compare
Ask for the whole price in writing, with everything the invoice would show, and put your own staff time, software, cover and training beside it. Moving payroll is also a piece of work in itself, so allow for it.
Talking this through with someone who runs payroll each month can help. Alpine would welcome that conversation, whichever way you are leaning.
This is general information, not advice on your own position.
Reviewed against official sources, November 2026.
Sources
Talk to Alpine
If you have a question about your own payroll, we would be pleased to hear from you.
Get in touch

