The six month unfair dismissal rule: why accurate start dates matter

This post keeps to the payroll side. Decisions about dismissal, probation and contracts belong with your employment adviser.
The wording that sets the date
HMRC's April bulletin says employees "who have at least 6 months of continuous employment on 1 January 2027 will be entitled to claim unfair dismissal". For dismissals with an effective date of termination before 1 January 2027, the 2 year period still applies. Existing day one protections are unchanged.
So the question for a given employee turns on how long they have been continuously employed.
A payroll date is a record, and the law has its own test
Section 211 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 says a period of continuous employment "begins with the day on which the employee starts work". As we read it, that may not be the date a payroll system shows. Someone's first pay date and their start date are different things, and a record keyed in later can carry the wrong one. Service can also run from an earlier date in some cases, such as a business transfer, so take advice on those people.
Start dates on the FPS
The same April bulletin covers the payroll mechanics:
| Situation | What HMRC asks for |
|---|---|
| A genuine new employment | Enter a start date, since missing start dates can cause HMRC systems to merge separate employments |
| A continuing employment | Leave the start date field blank |
| A payroll ID has changed | Tick the payroll ID change indicator and give both the old and new IDs |
That last row has a direct link to start dates. Errors occur, according to the bulletin, when employers submit a start date or a starter declaration in place of the indicator, which creates a second employment record for the same employee. A payroll ID change handled that way can therefore be treated by HMRC as a new job.
A sensible check
Our suggestion is a simple comparison, starting with anyone close to the 6 month mark on 1 January 2027. Set the contract, the offer letter and the payroll record side by side. Where they differ, find out which is right and correct the one that is wrong, using the right route for each.
It also helps to agree who confirms a start date to payroll for each new joiner, and when, so that the date is right from the first pay run.
HMRC's bulletins are the place to watch for further detail. Alpine is happy to talk through how start dates reach your payroll.
This is general information, not advice on your own position.
Reviewed against official sources, November 2026.
Sources
Talk to Alpine
If you have a question about your own payroll, we would be pleased to hear from you.
Get in touch

